AUTOBIOGRAPHICAL RAW MATERIAL UNSUITABLE FOR THE MINING OF FICTION, by Charles Yu
Chapter 1: Miscellaneous Intervals Involving My Mother
The structure of a proper goodbye works like this: there is a designated moment of leaving and there is a fixed quantity of wistfulness and usually the latter runs out just as the former comes to pass, resulting in neatly packaged episodes which build up to moments of emotional resonance to be dissected upon later reflection, when the details have been forgotten and stories can be made up.
* * *
Some notes on the Premature Goodbye
Sometimes, however, before the moment of leaving but after the decision to leave, there is a brief span of time, ranging from a few seconds to several minutes, when I am no longer present in, yet not quite absent from, my mother’s house.
What happens is that we run out of things to say to each other, run out of ways to say I miss you and you mean everything to me and so on and we end up just staring off into the backyard at the ivy plants and our rusting lawn chairs. What starts out as the longing for home weakens into longing for the idea of home which erodes into longing for the sake of longing, which eventually exhausts itself.
We drift off into different rooms. We wander around the house. We pretend to look for things. We pretend to forget things and sit around pretending to try to remember what we’re pretending to look for. We even pretend to look for things and then realize we’ve actually lost them. This is how we waste our time together: minute by minute.
* * *
Some titles of stories I would like to write someday
The Story of My Mother
My Mother: The Uncollected Stories
The Definitive Story of the Particular Sadness of My Mother
* * *
2m 06s
Another source of waste: time spent thinking about lost time. It goes like this:
Every Sunday night at eight, when it is almost time for me to leave, I start to regret all of the time I have wasted. Instead of talking to my mother, getting to know her, I have done nothing. Sat in front of the television. Looked through old baseball cards.
I start to think about lost time and this leads me to think about the fact that I am thinking about lost time, which leads me to realize that I will want it all back some day, all of which makes me start to regret the lost time spent thinking about lost time. Which leads me right back to where I started. And so on and so forth, until it’s time for me to go.
* * *
Some notes from the seventeenth draft of a story entitled Tying My Shoelaces While My Mother Looks On
It takes, on average, about eleven seconds for me to: (i) notice the untied shoelace, (ii) bend down, (iii) tie it and (iv) check the knot on my other shoe for soundness. These eleven seconds are spent in silence.
Assuming one of my shoes comes untied approximately one out of every ten times I visit, in a typical year I spend an extra 55 seconds with my mother due to untied shoelaces.
* * *
(0m 11s)
(I once had a dream in which I saw my whole life, past and future, spread out before me like a deck of playing cards fanned across the table. It was wondrous. There must have been millions, tens of millions, hundreds of millions of cards – my whole life – subdivided into slices of exactly eleven seconds. But the feeling of wonder gave way quickly to a sickening panic, as I looked closer and realized each and every piece was incomplete, cut by some devious method, some demon algorithm, some perfectly evil genius in such a way that no one card was a self-contained moment. Someone had managed it so that any single piece was completely worthless, a stretch of perfect insignificance, which made no sense, gave no solace, offered no closure.)
* * *
Some notes on the equivalence of time
I woke from the dream, my shirt heavy with sweat, and I knew this: some day all of those thin and delicate cards, lined up in their unique and pristine order, will be scattered, once and for all. Every last bit of fine structure, every intricate local pattern, will be violently and permanently erased. Any apparent design revealed as illusory. The entirety of my life, the sum total of all the sixty or seventy odd years I had been given to spend with my mother, to make her feel less alone, will have been wasted, spent cataloguing, anatomizing, epiphanizing.
At that moment, nothing in the world seemed half as absurd as trying to turn a sliver of life into, of all things, a short story. Where there had been tantalizing promises, near-connections, ephemeral and minute narrative arcs, one day there will just be a massive pile of my life, my mother’s life, our lives together, severed into countless eleven-second pieces.
It will probably happen in this house, with my mother and me and no one else to witness or, if we’re lucky, in a hospital, with a nurse and possibly even a doctor standing by. It will be a surprise, no matter when or where it happens. And when that deck gets reshuffled, in the chaos, in the maelstrom of cards flying around, I might have time enough to grab just one card for keeping, one card to hold on to. If the cards are cut the way I think they will be, each one meaningless on its own, then the eleven seconds spent tying my shoe while my mother looks on will be as good as any.
* * *
Some notes on the practical limits of longing
I used to think that every time I left my mother, it broke her heart. The truth is, it doesn’t really break either of our hearts. I wish it did, but it doesn’t. We are a family of two, each of us alone in the world but for the other, and yet leaving is somehow bearable. Too bearable. Unbearably bearable. It almost breaks my heart how bearable it is. But it doesn’t, maybe because we both have our own lives, lonely and quiet as they may be. Or maybe because it just is not very practical to let our hearts break, once a week, right on schedule. Whatever the reason may be, the fact remains that it does not break my mother’s heart and it does not break my heart, and that’s almost enough to break my heart.
* * *
Some notes I try to shoehorn into every story I write
All of my stories start out as uncarved blocks of time and end up as (i) a finished sculpted figure and (ii) a pile of left over pieces. When I’m done cutting and chipping and breaking, and for the first time step back to look at what I’ve made, I am always disappointed. The figure I’ve carved is never what I thought it would be. What I thought was form is a twisted, grotesque shape and what I thought was rich particularity is no more than an accumulation of idiosyncrasies. And what I thought were bold lines turn out to be jagged edges. Details that should be in the story are not and details that were necessary have been left out and details of both kinds have been lost, wasted, misplaced forever, unexamined and unexplained.
* * *
Definition of Frictional Loss of Time from the System
A secondary effect. An indirect source of lost fictional material. It is a by-product of the differing rhythms of (i) humans and (ii) the machines humans use to connect, record and transport themselves and each other. Physical constraints include maximum operating speeds and minimum latency periods for such machines. Waiting at stoplights, waiting in elevators, waiting for phones to be picked up. I have lost innumerable stories to these frictions, the miscellaneous seconds and minutes dissipating like heat.
* * *
57m 44s
The first story I ever lost to the Premature Goodbye was at the airport, the day I left for medical school. After a long and tearful goodbye, it was announced over the PA that Flight 2011, offering non-stop service from LAX to Logan, had been delayed for another hour. My mother and I looked at each other, unsure of what to do. After so much hand-wringing and wishing for an extra minute with each other, here we were presented with an entire hour, out of thin air. It was slightly embarrassing to have so much time and nothing else to say. We sat silently in our chairs, and then, after a minute or two, I wandered over to the magazine stand to browse. My mother bought a candy bar and walked over to watch the planes taking off. When it was finally time to go, we parted amiably, like acquaintances. I said I’d call and she just nodded.
What started out as a moment of departure and loss, a potential short story, withered into a non-event. It was not unlike what happens when two people who have just parted ways realize they are leaving in the same direction. One of two things can happen. Some people will turn toward each other and give an awkward little chuckle, as in, ha-ha, we said goodbye but here we are, we’re walking together.
Some people, however, for reasons that can’t be explained, will continue to walk in the same direction, side by side, neither one acknowledging the other. It’s as if some Designated Time of Leaving has occurred.
* * *
Some general notes on the use of particulars
There are stories about other people’s mothers that are well told, that I can relate to, see points of intersection, say to myself, once or twice or five times, yes, yes, true, yes, that’s right, mmhmm yup.
Then there are stories about other people’s mothers that are so well told that after reading them, I immediately go to my desk and throw away everything I am working on, in a fit of self-disgust.
* * *
Some notes from the Pre-Empted Stories File
And then there are those stories, other people’s stories, about their mothers, that are so well told that they have the alarming and uncomfortable effect of making the hairs on my neck stand up, of giving me goose bumps on my head. They make me sit up when I read them, repeatedly, obsessively flipping back the page to look again and again at the name of the author, to stare at it as if to ask who is this person who knows my own mother better than I do? When I am reading these stories I want to stop, I need to stop, because each word is like a tiny injury, a sharp, angled blow to the edifice of my ego.
I want to stop but of course I cannot stop, I cannot do anything except for continue reading, word for word for word until I am gulping the words down in whole sentences, accumulating injuries. And at some point I realize I am actually mouthing the words as I read them, even before I read them and I wonder, how am I doing this? and for an instant the thought occurs to me that this person must have stolen my brain waves or at least my hard disk but that reflexive suspicion is quickly replaced by the realization that abstract premises, that is, potential stories, exist independently of the would-be writers trying to capture them, that someone has simply beaten me to the punch. Whereas I had seen this uncarved block, waiting to be worked on, but had passed, unsure of what to do with it, someone else, this other person, had taken that very block and broken it open, chipped away at it, chiseled it into individual words, feelings, moments, people. Someone else had gone out and done it first and I am left to find another way to tell the story of my own mother.
* * *
Autobiographical Raw Material Unsuitable for the Mining of Fiction
The Definitive Story of the Particular Sadness of My Mother sits on my desk, uncarved, shiny and untouched. I have no idea what it’s supposed to look like when it’s done. I don’t even know where to begin.
This is the extent of what I know. It will be complicated. It will have to include:
– a hysterectomy,
– ovarian cysts,
– a middling job neither menial enough to be comic nor substantial enough to take seriously,
– three quiet, unmarried sisters, mysteries to each other and themselves,
– scattered friends who slipped into acquaintances as years went on,
– my father, who ran away and reportedly drank himself to death.
It will probably also have to include the day my father left. That he shaved, showered, ate breakfast, kissed my mother on the cheek, grabbed his briefcase and went out the door. That we knew he wasn’t coming back. How the kiss on the cheek gave it away, because he had never done that before. It will have to include the fact that before my father had even reached the corner stop sign, my mother was in my room giving me a look which explained that we would never again utter his name. Not out loud, not to each other, not in the house.
It may also include the following: how I told myself that day that I would work hard, study hard, learn to write. That I would get good enough, steal enough from others and some day make a story out of the random and arbitrary disasters of my mother’s life. I would put the pieces in order for her, act one, act two, scene four, scene five, fill it all in with the right colors. The story of my mother should describe how we silently agreed that I was going to make sense of it all, sort out her life and come back one day and say, look, this is why this happened and you did this much, and you were the most this, or the least this, and this mattered and so did this. It should explain that we both kept hope that there would come the time when we’d have some long stretch of hours, or days, or a week, to sit in a quiet room and I’d tell my mother the story of her own life, recite it back to her, a new thing, show her where it was funny and who mattered. I’d show her the one story in the world in which she was the main character, because she was too tired to keep trying to do it herself. I came back from college and I went away again and came back again and moved back in and then moved out. The whole time I was collecting details, piecing them together in little clumps, here and there, starting to see the beginnings of a plot.
Then one day I woke up and my mother had gotten old. And I had become not so young and I went to my desk to look at the story and there were hundreds of new pieces, a secret store of senseless hurts, routine indignities, pointless hours. All of my work, all of the partial narratives I had been pasting and stapling and forcing together, it was all junk. The Story of My Mother had to include more fragments, more ingredients, more random intervals than I had ever imagined. And right then and there, I realized for the first time that I was not good enough to write it, realized that it was quite possible I would never be good enough, even if I had a thousand years. I realized that writing the story of my mother will require someone who can leave it all hanging, someone comfortable with ambiguity. Someone with the ability to leave things out. I don’t know how to do any of these things.
This is what I know how to do: cling to sentiment, collect the scraps, stockpile every last anonymous moment in my mother’s anonymous existence. I’ve created a big box for all of it and labeled it Miscellaneous. And in that box are millions of files, one for every unclassifiable moment in my mother’s non-fictional life. Every eleven seconds a new file is created. I label it whatever seems appropriate. This is what I’ve settled for: the secret, deluded hope that someday, if I keep all of these useless bits together in one place and stare at them long enough, I’ll figure out how to arrange them in just the right way.
Charles Yu’s work has appeared in the Harvard Review.